I. RESULT OF SELECTION 1. Name and address of the selected asset auction organization: - Thanh An Auction Joint Stock Company - Address: No. 266 Ha Huy Tap, Yen Vien town, Gia Lam district, Ha Noi city. 2. Total points of the selected asset auction organization: 86 3. The asset auction organization’s file is refused to be considered and evaluated with reasons for refusal (nếu có): No. II. SCORE RESULTS (including selected property auction organization):

No.	Criteria	Thanh An Auction Joint Stock Company	Song Pha Auction Joint Stock Company	Ben Thanh Auction Joint Stock Company	Sao Viet Auction Joint Stock Company
I	Necessary facilities and equipment for the auction and the type of auctioned asset	23	22	22	22
1	Facilities	11	11	11	11
2	Necessary equipment	8	8	8	8
3	Own an active website	2	2	2	2
4	Approved by the competent authority to be eligible for the online auction form	1 (Department of Justice directly issued)	0 (No information)	0 (rent the third online auction site)	0 (No information)
5	Own place to store auction records	1	1	1	1
II	Feasible and effective auction plan	22	22	22	22
1	The proposed auction plan must be organized in accordance with the law, ensuring publicity, transparency and objectivity.	4	4	4	4
2	The auction plan proposes a time and place to sell and receive auction participation file, a place to hold the auction, and a price announcement meeting for all the auction participants; the auction form, price step, number of auction rounds are feasible and highly effective	4	4	4	4
3	The auction plan proposes ways to secure information, prevent collusion and lowering prices	4	4	4	4
4	The auction plan proposes more locations, other forms of listing, and other public announcements to increase the dissemination of the auction	4	4	4	4
5	The auction plan proposes solutions to ensure safety, security and order for the the auction	3	3	3	3
6	The auction plan proposes solutions to situations arising in the course of the auction	3	3	3	3
III	Competence, experience and reputation of the asset auction organization	36	33	28	30
1	In the preceding year, an auction service contract of the same type of property as the property expected to be auctioned was conduct	6	4 (according to the list of auction service contract implemented in 2021)	2 (not listed for the preceding year)	3 (according to the list of auction service contract implemented in 2021)
2	In the preceding year, auctions of the same type of property as the property expected to be auctioned was conducted, existed an average difference between the winning bid price and the starting price	10 (According to the provisioning profile)	12 (According to the provisioning profile)	10 (Do not provide a list of all auctions of the type in the previous year)	10 (Do not provide a list of all auctions of the type in the previous year)
3	The operation time in the field of asset auction from the issuance of Establishment Decision or  from the time received operation registration certificate (Certificate of business registration for asset auction enterprises established before the effective date of the Law on Asset Auction)	5	4 (The company was established and auctioned from July 2018)	4 (The company was established and auctioned from July 2018)	5
4	Number of auctioneers of the asset auction organization	3	3	2	2
5	Practice experience of auctioneers of asset auction organizations	4	4	4	4
6	Pay corporate income tax or contribute to the State budget in the preceding year, except value-added tax	4	2 (there is no document showing)	2	2
7	Staff have labor contract	3	3	3	3
8	Having a trainee work in an asset auction organization in the preceding year or the year in which the application for registration is submitted	1	1	1	1
IV	ꦺAppropriate remuneration for auction services and property auction costs	5 ( 35% off)	5 ( 25% off)	5 ( 30% off)	5 (35% off)
V	Other criteria suitable for auctioned assets decided by a department has authority in debt settlement	0	0	0	0
Total score		86	82	77	79